Saul's Music Space

[(poco) Sforzando]

If you want I can provide the score, its really fun to play.

Provide away, I could use some fun.

[Saul]

Here's the Score:

[Mirror Image]

I really don't know why you are such an angry little miserable human being who just cant be happy for someone who shares with you an email from a guy that enjoyed my music?

I warned you on our interaction in email that you need to stop chasing me around and commenting about every little thing I write. This is called abusive behavior.
A normal human being would encourage young musicians who want to create art, not laugh them down, laughing down on people is extremely rude and exceedingly insensitive.
I wish that you will drop this behavior that got you in permanent trouble on the other site, and start behaving towards other members with respect and dignity, this is the minimum that is required from an adult thinking person.

If you can't behave this way, then there is something really wrong with you.

Saul, allow me to explain to you my view on your composing and I will try to be as objective as I can:

Problem #1: Notation

You continue to display poor notation as many have suggested to you. You write parts for instruments that are incredibly hard to play. I would seriously think about getting a good theory teacher that is well grounded in all periods of classical music and can show you how to notate music properly.

Problem #2: YouTube

People on YouTube don't matter. The people that should matter to you right now should be the musicians that are going to perform your music. If you continue to experience problem #1, you will not have any serious musician interested in your music. You have to listen to what composers and musicians tell you about your music. Getting praise from Billy Bob who doesn't know a damn thing about classical music doesn't mean crap in the concert hall.

Problem #3: Self-criticism and Listening to other's opinions

You seem to think everything you compose is good and the general problem you exhibit is there's not a problem with the music. I'm not sure how much music you composed and quite frankly don't care because I can tell by the playback of your music that not much time has been spent thinking about what you want to say musically. You have to be tougher on yourself. If you can't critique your own music, then how can you possibly critize another composer's music?

[Saul]

MI

You're ignored, so save the trouble , I will not read or respond to your comments until you drop this attitude of putting people down and laughing at them.

When I will see a change I'll remove you from my ignore list.

[(poco) Sforzando]

MI

You're ignored, so save the trouble , I will not read or respond to your comments until you drop this attitude of putting people down and laughing at them.

When I will see a change I'll remove you from my ignore list.

His last comment to you was serious, and I thought respectful.

[Mirror Image]

MI

You're ignored, so save the trouble , I will not read or respond to your comments until you drop this attitude of putting people down and laughing at them.

When I will see a change I'll remove you from my ignore list.

Again, ignoring other people's opinions. You're surely setting yourself up for failure. I give you practical advice and you continue to believe there is nothing wrong with the music you continue to produce.

This isn't YouTube where all the birds sing praises for your music in unison, this is a classical forum with some very knowledgeable people trying to help you, but if you're looking for nothing but positive reinforcement, then perhaps you should stay on YouTube.

[Saul]

His last comment to you was serious, and I thought respectful.

Lets see if he can behave normally for a month or two, then maybe I'll take him off my ignore list. One post or two don't cut it for me.

[Mirror Image]

Lets see if he can behave normally for a month or two, then maybe I'll take him of my ignore list. One post or two don't cut it for me.

You think putting me on ignore is going to make me become a less-opinionated person and that this time spent not reading my posts will make me somehow sing praises for your music?

I think you're running from the problem, Saul. The problem isn't with me giving you my opinion, the problem lies with your own insecurity and constant need for approval.

Put me on ignore, don't put me on ignore, the problem with your general attitude about music and the fundamental problems with your music isn't going to go away.

[Saul]

I can only wonder why you cant leave me alone.

Just leave me alone, please.

[Mirror Image]

I can only wonder why you cant leave me alone.

Just leave me alone, please.

It's not that I can't leave you alone, it's that I wonder why you can't understand what I'm trying to tell you? I'm trying to help you out.

[Saul]

I want you to give it a break and just leave me alone, that's all.

I have ignored you, and you're still trolling around my music page.

If you don't like me, or my music, just leave me alone, a simple request by all accounts.

Just leave.

[Mirror Image]

I want you to give it a break and just leave me alone, that's all.

I have ignored you, and you're still trolling around my music page.

If you don't like me, or my music, just leave me alone, a simple request by all accounts.

Just leave.

This isn't your anything, Saul. This is a forum. But since you seem to not be able to take any kind of criticism and you don't exhibit any interest in becoming a better composer, then your wish is granted I shall leave.

[Saul]

Thank Goodness.

[Mirror Image]

Thank Goodness.

On second thought, I'll stick around and critique your music some more since this is what you don't want.   Is there anyway I can get tickets to the latest piano recital with that retarded dwarf who performs your music regularly?

[Mirror Image]

Too bad you were born without a brain.

But don't worry, you'll get over it.

Too bad you'll never get a good music theory teacher as you really need one.

P.S. I see you deleted this comment you made. That's okay. I quoted it for you just as a reminder.

[Saul]

You're an obsessive ignorant man.

[Saul]

Anyways back to the topic.

Currently I'm working on two piano works.
The first one is in B flat major, its sort of a military march type of music, lots of chords.

The other one is more baroque like fantasia in D minor.

I'm trying to build the entire pieces from the piano, without writing anything down. I will begin to put it on paper when the entire structures of these pieces are complete.

I also contemplate about returning to do some work on my D minor String Quartet, I didn't work on it for about 4 years.

[Mirror Image]

You're an obsessive ignorant man.

Yeah, I'm ignorant for thinking that you would actually learn from your mistakes, but alas, you continue to make one notation mistake after another.

[Mirror Image]

Anyways back to the topic.

Currently I'm working on two piano works.
The first one is in B flat major, its sort of a military march type of music, lots of chords.

The other one is more baroque like fantasia in D minor.

I'm trying to build the entire pieces from the piano, without writing anything down. I will begin to put it on paper when the entire structures of these pieces are complete.

I also contemplate about returning to do some work on my D minor String Quartet, I didn't work on it for about 4 years.

Why do you continue to compose when your music is so poorly notated and has been pretty much critized since you started this thread?

Like I said, this isn't YouTube where all the birds sing praises to your music.

[Saul]

You're a crazy man, leave me alone, leave.
No more replys to you.

Just Leave.