Saul's Music Space

[Saul]

Does anyone on either side think that this dead horse is really worth beating any more?

And who are you ?

Scarpia?

What are you who are you ? and what have you done?


I at least create music that some people enjoy, and what have you done with your life?

Coming  here and lecturing people about nothing.

[Saul]

A great milestone post, Scarps. 

Another total nobody.

[DavidW]

Both the score and the midi of the first movement can be found here:

Score page 95

http://www.good-music-guide.com/community/index.php/topic,92.msg444980.html#msg444980

Midi page 89

http://www.good-music-guide.com/community/index.php/topic,92.msg436576.html#msg436576

Thanks Saul!   Oh man I hate midis, I'll just wait for the real thing.

[Scarpia]

And who are you ?

Scarpia?

What are you who are you ? and what have you done?


I at least create music that some people enjoy, and what have you done with your life?

Coming  here and lecturing people about nothing.

I actually have done a few things in my life.  But I would have though my suggestion would seem reasonable, regardless of any credentials I might have. 

[Saul]

Thanks Saul!   Oh man I hate midis, I'll just wait for the real thing.

No problem,

But dont you agree that someone should teach Scarpia and the other chesssssss Playaaaa some basic manners?

[Saul]

I actually have done a few things in my life.  But I would have though my suggestion would seem reasonable, regardless of any credentials I might have.

Your suggestion is worthless and was meant to generate hate.

Love is all you need, you hate the beatles man?!

[Philoctetes]

I actually have done a few things in my life.  But I would have though my suggestion would seem reasonable, regardless of any credentials I might have.

I've heard good things about him on youtube.

[Mirror Image]

Well, I consider your Viola Sonata a total waste of paper and time, an utterly useless work in my opinion.

I didn't write this as an affront or for any other reason or as a get back, I just don't like this kind of music, and I believe you did  a masterful job in creating the music that I cant stand and find no value in.

Had anyone else wrote it, I would have said the same thing.

Schoenberg's and Webern's music is also horrible music for me, which I consider a waste of space in the cosmos of this universe.

So you are in good company, its nothing personal.

If you want to impress me, which I gather you don't, you would have written something that had more order, charm, and natural progression from one theme to the next, in short some realistically sounding melodies and themes which are evident for the ear and mind to grasp.

In fact, I believe this is your worst work ever, I think you should stick with the Vocal Stuff, there at least you have some sense of inspiration. But this Viola sonata is your poorest achievement as of yet.

You know better then me that not everything that is performed means that its good.
Horrible composers many at times showcase their skills to the public not because they have something good to sell, but because they have better connections then most other musicians, don't play it like you don't know this Karl.



Now if you really want to impress me please write something along this line...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3KCi8R9P-g

You think Karl's intentions for writing music is to impress your backwards way of looking at music? You live in the past, you continue to not acknowledge what is around you, you live in seclusion and are afraid to accept the reality we live in. You continue to compose music that does nothing for anyone. I bet if Bach, Mozart, or Beethoven were alive today they would laugh at you. Not because you're trying to be a composer, but because you continue to write music that has no kind of feeling and expresses nothing. You show no command of music theory. You continue to deny the music of the 20th Century, which for me and many others, was one of the greatest periods for classical music. You continue to deny the influence of the Second Viennese School and you look at what these composers did as something that is atrocious when the reality is they had more influence on music in the 20th Century than your little faux-Bach pieces had on YouTube. They impacted music while you continue to go unperformed.

The brutal truth of the matter is you'll never become a good composer if you don't acknowledge your weaknesses and start being much more concerned with the music you actually want to compose.

[Saul]

I've heard good things about him on youtube.

Are you Nassrallah by any chance?

LOL love those photos...

[Philoctetes]

Are you Nassrallah by any chance?

LOL love those photos...

I wish.

Glad you enjoyed the photos. 

[Saul]

The funny thing is I finally put MI on ignore and I wont be seeing or hearing anything of him for a good time. Thanks for the power of the iggy button!

[Saul]

I wish.

Glad you enjoyed the photos. 

If you really wish that, perhaps someone should report you to the homeland security branch...

[Scarpia]

The funny thing is I finally put MI on ignore and I wont be seeing or hearing anything of him for a good time. Thanks for the power of the iggy button!

Then you won't know what he is writing, and what we are all reading about you.   

[Philoctetes]

If you really wish that, perhaps someone should report you to the homeland security branch...

If they haven't done it for things past; I doubt they'll do it for things present.

[Saul]

Then you won't know what he is writing, and what we are all reading about you.   

Ask me if my left toe cares?

[Scarpia]

Ask me if my left toe cares?

Judging by how you respond to every post he has made until now, you seem to care a lot. 

[Saul]

Judging by how you respond to every post he has made until now, you seem to care a lot.

I actually don't care otherwise I would respond, I tried to make him stop spamming my page, but there is nothing more that I can do then just ignore him until he betters his ways.

[Saul]

If they haven't done it for things past; I doubt they'll do it for things present.

I wonder why you want to be someone that chants 'death to Amercia', perhaps you should move to Lebanon.

[Mirror Image]

I actually don't care otherwise I would respond, I tried to make him stop spamming my page, but there is nothing more that I can do then just ignore him until he betters his ways.

This isn't YOUR page! How many times do I have point this out to you? You don't own GMG. I can post on your page as much as I like and if by chance you actually do read one of my posts regarding your composing, then I did my job.

[Philoctetes]

This isn't YOUR page! How many times do I have point this out to you? You don't own GMG. I can post on your page as much as I like and if by chance you actually do read one of my posts regarding your composing, then I did my job.

I'll be perfectly honest. You're becoming more annoying than Saul.