Saul's Compositions

[J.Z. Herrenberg]

It is - and remains - Saul's call.

[Saul]

You guys are all Trolls!

[J.Z. Herrenberg]

You guys are all Trolls!

Stop feeding us then. 

[MN Dave]

Yes, WE'RE the trolls.

[Cato]

You guys are all Trolls!

Have you considered submitting your compositions for criticism from a music professor?

I have made this suggestion to you before: if you think you have talent, you will need to take it beyond the saulemn self-pollination of the autodidact, and see if you can develop your skills to higher levels.

[(poco) Sforzando]

Have you considered submitting your compositions for criticism from a music professor?

I have made this suggestion to you before: if you think you have talent, you will need to take it beyond the saulemn self-pollination of the autodidact, and see if you can develop your skills to higher levels.

I doubt that will fly with Saul. "Criticism" of Saul is by definition false; "praise" is true.

[J.Z. Herrenberg]

I have made this suggestion to you before: if you think you have talent, you will need to take it beyond the saulemn self-pollination of the autodidact, and see if you can develop your skills to higher levels.

[Saul]

Have you considered submitting your compositions for criticism from a music professor?

I have made this suggestion to you before: if you think you have talent, you will need to take it beyond the saulemn self-pollination of the autodidact, and see if you can develop your skills to higher levels.

I have done that by now.

You're still stuck in the 18th century....

[Cato]

I have done that by now.

You're still stuck in the 18th century....

Nonsense!  I will have you know that I am stuck in the 1st century B.C.!!!

And so which professor was this?  And what did (s)he say?

[Saul]

Nonsense!  I will have you know that I am stuck in the 1st century B.C.!!!

And so which professor was this?  And what did (s)he say?

I have shown my music to a concert Pianist in Julliard some 5 years ago, he liked some of my compositions and even took one of my works to show to his Professor. He did suggest that I should begin to study composition on a formal level.

Second person was my Piano Teacher who happens to be a great pianist and a Bach Expert, she was giving Master classes on Chopin in Brooklyn College. She loved some of my Ideas and the images that I create in music, she didn't tell me to study composition on a formal level. Third person was a Professor of Cello here in Brooklyn. I wanted to hire him together with his fellow musicians to perform my String Quartet in B flat major. He listened to it and did like it, but demanded a price tag for his services that I just couldn't afford.

Thats what I can remember now...

[ChamberNut]

Saul, do you by any chance know Naftali Schindler?

[Cato]

I have shown my music to a concert Pianist in Julliard some 5 years ago, he liked some of my compositions and even took one of my works to show to his Professor. He did suggest that I should begin to study composition on a formal level
Thats what I can remember now...

I will suggest the same!

[Saul]

I will suggest the same!

Ok thats cool...

[Don]

Saul:

Many classical music lovers doodle around with composition and realize that they possess minimal inspiration in this field.  You just haven't arrived at that point yet.

[MN Dave]

Saul's Smorgasbord?

[ChamberNut]

Missa Saulemnis

[Saul]

Saul's Smorgasbord?

Can you stop allready, you sound like a 2 year old, what a loser you are.

[Saul]

Missa Saulemnis

And you are nuts... hows that now?

[Saul]

Saul:

Many classical music lovers doodle around with composition and realize that they possess minimal inspiration in this field.  You just haven't arrived at that point yet.

Oh... said by non other then the great one DON... THE ALL KNOWING BIG SHOT !

[Don]

Oh... said by non other then the great one DON... THE ALL KNOWING BIG SHOT !

I'm just telling you what I hear through your musical submittals.  By the way, I never said I have composed anything decent. 

If you get a kick out of creating music, that's great.  But don't presume that what you write is worthy of my time.